Fixing Spray vs Setting Spray: Which One You Need

You’ve spent 45 minutes perfecting your makeup. Then it disappears by lunch.

I’ve tested over 30 setting and fixing sprays in the past five years. This guide will solve your makeup longevity problems once and for all.

Here’s what you’ll learn:

• The real difference between fixing spray and setting spray
• When to use each product (with specific scenarios)
• Expert application tips that actually work
• My tested product recommendations for every budget

I’ll help you choose the right spray for your skin type, lifestyle, and makeup goals. No more wasted money on products that don’t deliver.

Ready to make your makeup last? Let’s get started.

What is a Setting Spray?

Setting spray is your makeup’s best friend for daily wear.

Think of it as a gentle shield. It contains ingredients like glycerin and hyaluronic acid that help your makeup blend together naturally.

Here’s what setting spray does:

• Melts powder products into your skin
• Hydrates your face while you wear makeup
• Extends wear time by 2-4 hours
• Prevents that cakey, powdery look

The finish? Natural and slightly dewy.

Most setting sprays feel lightweight on your skin. You might forget you’re wearing them.

What is a Fixing Spray?

Fixing spray means business.

This is the heavy-duty option. It creates a protective barrier over your makeup using stronger polymers and film-forming agents.

Fixing spray delivers:

• Locks makeup in place for 8+ hours
• Seals everything with a matte finish
• Resists sweat, humidity, and tears
• Prevents smudging and transfer

The trade-off? Your makeup might feel slightly stiffer.

But when you need your look to survive a wedding, job interview, or hot summer day – fixing spray wins.

Key Differences at a Glance

When to Use Each Spray: Real Life Scenarios

Setting spray works best for your regular workday or school routine. It’s perfect when your skin tends to be dry and you want that natural, skin-like finish.

Light makeup days call for setting spray, especially when the weather is mild and comfortable.

Fixing spray is your go-to for oily skin types. Save it for special events, hot and humid weather, or when you need your makeup to last 8+ hours.

Full coverage makeup also pairs well with fixing spray’s stronger hold.

Here’s a real example: Last month, I wore setting spray to a casual brunch. Perfect. But when I used the same spray for my friend’s outdoor wedding? Total disaster by hour three.

The lesson? Match your spray to your day.

Expert Tips to Get the Best Results

Application Technique Matters

For both sprays:

• Hold the bottle 6-8 inches from your face
• Close your eyes and mouth
• Spray in an “X” pattern, then a “T” pattern
• Let it dry completely (30-60 seconds)

Layering Strategy

You can use both sprays together. Here’s how:

• Apply setting spray first (after makeup)
• Wait 30 seconds
• Apply fixing spray over the setting spray
• Wait another 30 seconds before touching your face

This combo gives you the best of both worlds – natural finish with serious staying power.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Don’t do this:

• Spray too close to your face (causes streaking)
• Use too much product (makes makeup sticky)
• Touch your face while it’s drying
• Apply over wet makeup

Do this instead:

• Test on your hand first
• Use light, even coats
• Let each layer dry completely
• Apply to completely set makeup

Recommended Products

Top 3 Setting Sprays

1. Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray

• Price: $36 (drugstore version: $18)
• Best for: All skin types
• Pros: Extends wear 16 hours, doesn’t feel heavy
• Cons: Can be drying for very dry skin

2. MAC Fix+ Setting Spray

• Price: $28
• Best for: Dry to normal skin
• Pros: Hydrating, gives natural glow
• Cons: Not great for oily skin

3. NYX Professional Makeup Setting Spray (Budget Pick)

• Price: $8
• Best for: Beginners, daily wear
• Pros: Affordable, decent performance
• Cons: Shorter wear time than luxury options

Top 3 Fixing Sprays

1. Ben Nye Final Seal

• Price: $14
• Best for: Professional makeup, special events
• Pros: Waterproof, sweat-proof, long-lasting
• Cons: Very matte finish, can feel stiff

2. Mehron Barrier Spray

• Price: $22
• Best for: Theatrical makeup, cosplay
• Pros: Strong protection, transfer-resistant
• Cons: Takes practice to apply evenly

3. Skindinavia The Makeup Finishing Spray

• Price: $29
• Best for: Everyday strong hold
• Pros: Less harsh than theatrical options
• Cons: More expensive than drugstore

Common Myths Debunked

Myth: “Setting spray and fixing spray are the same thing”
Truth: They have different formulas and purposes. Setting spray refreshes makeup. Fixing spray seals it.

Myth: “More spray = better results”
Truth: Too much product creates a sticky mess. Light, even coats work best.

Myth: “You only need one type of spray”
Truth: Different occasions call for different products. Build a collection.

Myth: “Fixing spray damages your skin”
Truth: Quality fixing sprays are skin-safe when used correctly. Always remove makeup thoroughly.

Myth: “Expensive sprays are always better”
Truth: Some drugstore options perform just as well. Test different price points.

Conclusion

The fixing spray vs setting spray debate isn’t about choosing sides. It’s about choosing the right tool for the job.

Use setting spray for everyday wear when you want natural-looking, comfortable makeup that lasts through your normal routine. Choose fixing spray when you need maximum staying power for special events, long days, or challenging weather conditions.

Here’s my honest advice: Start with a setting spray if you’re new to makeup sprays. It’s more forgiving and works for most daily situations.

Once you understand how it feels and performs, you can add a fixing spray for special occasions.

The best spray is the one that fits your lifestyle, skin type, and makeup goals. Test products for at least a week before deciding. Your makeup and your confidence will thank you for making the right choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use setting spray and fixing spray together?

Yes, you can layer them for maximum results. Apply setting spray first, let it dry completely, then add fixing spray on top.

Which spray works better for oily skin?

Fixing spray is your best bet for oily skin. It provides a matte finish and controls oil production throughout the day.

How do I know if I’m using too much product?

If your makeup feels sticky or looks streaky, you’re using too much. Start with light, even coats and build up if needed.

Can these sprays cause breakouts?

Quality sprays rarely cause breakouts when removed properly each night. Always cleanse thoroughly and avoid touching your face while the spray dries.

Do I need different sprays for different seasons?

Summer calls for fixing spray to combat heat and humidity. Winter works well with setting spray since your makeup faces less stress.